How to shuffle rows in random order in SQL and save results in new table?

So I have a table called Customers

                     id  | name
                    ------------
                     1     Tom
                     2     Bob
                     3     Sam
                     4     Angel
                     5     Joe

I want to select the rows in the 'name' column in a random order, and insert those rows into a new table, I tried this

       select Name into TestTable from Customer order by NEWID() 
       select * from TestTable

But it doesn't work? The rows in TestTable are in the same order as they were in the original table.

                         Tom
                         Bob
                         Sam
                         Angel
                         Joe

I tried executing multiple times but the result is the same every time. It seems that the rows are being inserted into the new table before the randomization happens. Any ideas?